Changing US Broker: How to Move Your US Shares from a US custodian

There are many Australian investors holding US shares through an offshore brokerage account set up years ago. Often through an old adviser, introducing broker or a platform that has since changed hands. Over time service drops off, fees go up or the original adviser is no longer involved and investors want to move. The good news is that you can easily move your US shares to a new broker without selling them. US custodians have standard transfer systems, but there is strict paperwork and small mismatches can stall a transfer for weeks.

This practical guide explains how a transfer works, what you'll need and how Carnbrea can help you move US held assets from custodians such as StoneX, Pershing, Citi and Velocity Trade among others.

Understand How Your Assets Are Held

Before starting a transfer, confirm how and where your assets are held. Most US brokerage accounts fall into one of these categories:

  • Clearing firm custody: Your account is held at a US clearing firm such as StoneX, Pershing or Velocity Clearing, often through an introducing broker or adviser. Your statements may carry the introducing broker's name rather than the custodian's.

  • DRS (Direct Registration System): Shares are held directly with a transfer agent such as Computershare, EQ or Broadridge rather than with a broker.

  • Physical certificates: Older holdings may still exist in paper form and need to be deposited before they can be moved.

Your most recent statement will usually show the custodian, your account number and the exact registration, which are the details needed to start a transfer.

How a Broker-to-Broker Transfer Works

Most transfers between US custodians use the ACATS (Automated Customer Account Transfer Service) system. The transfer is started by the receiving broker, not the broker you're leaving. Once you've opened a new account and signed a transfer request, your new broker asks your existing custodian to move the assets.

Transfers can be:

  • Full transfers: The whole account, including all positions and cash, is moved and the old account is closed.

  • Partial transfers: Only the securities or cash you specify are moved.

Your holdings move "in kind", so the shares themselves are transferred and you don't need to sell first. This avoids triggering a sale and having to buy back in later.

Account Registration Must Match Exactly

The most common reason transfers are rejected is a registration mismatch. The name and account type at the new broker must match the account you're transferring from. For example:

  • An individual account must transfer to an individual account in the same name.

  • A joint account must transfer to a joint account with the same holders.

  • An entity account must transfer to an account in the same entity name, with the same trustee or director details.

If you want to change ownership as part of the move, such as moving shares from an individual name into an SMSF, that's a change of beneficial ownership. It's handled separately, usually needs extra documentation and may include a Medallion Signature Guarantee. It can also have tax consequences.

Account Types Carnbrea Can Offer

Carnbrea can open US trading accounts to match your existing structure, so your assets have the right place to land:

  • Individual and joint accounts: For personal investors holding US shares in their own name.

  • SMSF accounts: For self-managed super funds with individual or corporate trustees.

  • Trust accounts: For family trusts, discretionary trusts and unit trusts.

  • Company accounts: For Australian proprietary companies and other corporate entities.

  • IRA accounts: For clients holding US Individual Retirement Accounts, including those who have moved to Australia and want to keep their retirement assets invested and managed.

IRA transfers need particular care. They should be done as a direct custodian-to-custodian transfer so they aren't treated as a distribution. Clients with IRAs should get independent US and Australian tax advice before acting.

Prepare Your Documentation

To open your new account and start the transfer, you'll typically need:

  • Certified identification for all account holders, trustees, directors or signatories

  • A recent statement from your current custodian showing the account number and holdings

  • Entity documents, such as the trust deed, company extract or SMSF details

  • A completed W-8BEN (individuals) or W-8BEN-E (entities) to confirm your foreign tax status

  • A signed transfer authority

Make sure names, addresses and account numbers match your existing statement exactly. Differences such as a missing middle name or an old address can cause the transfer to be rejected.

Check for Assets That May Not Transfer

Not every holding can move through ACATS. Watch out for:

  • Fractional shares: These usually can't be transferred and may be sold for cash.

  • Proprietary or restricted products: Some funds or products are only available at the original custodian.

  • OTC or delisted securities: These may need special handling or a separate process.

  • Open options or margin balances: You may need to close these or settle them before the transfer.

We'll review your statement before submitting the request, so these issues are identified upfront rather than holding up the transfer midway.

What Happens After the Transfer

Once the assets arrive, we'll check them against your previous statement, including quantities and cash balances. Ask your previous custodian for your cost base and transaction history, because this information doesn't always come across with the transfer. You'll need it for Australian capital gains tax reporting.

Final Thoughts

Changing US brokers can feel daunting, especially when your account sits with a clearing firm you've never dealt with directly. With the right account structure, matching registration details and complete documentation, moving your US assets is a straightforward process.

Carnbrea's International Trading Desk handles the process from account opening through to transfer completion. We deal directly with custodians so you don't have to, and once your assets arrive we can provide ongoing access to US markets.

This information is provided by Carnbrea & Co Limited ABN 33 004 739 655, Australian Financial Services Licence No. 233763. Any advice included in this document is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on the advice, you should consider whether it is appropriate to you. If a product we recommend has a Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) or a Prospectus, you should read it before making a decision. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Derivatives are leveraged products which means gains and losses are magnified and you may lose substantially more than your initial investment. We do not endorse any information from research providers that we provide to you, unless we specifically say so.

Previous
Previous

Dying with US Assets: IRS Transfer Certificates, US Probate

Next
Next

What Computershare US Require for Share Transfers